Improving Council meetings

The efficient and effective functioning of Council meetings is important.  The community expects nothing less.

Upon assuming the mayoralty again in May 2016, I set about improving councillor and public gallery behaviour at our Council meetings.

Prior to my election, our meetings had become dysfunctional and unpleasant.  Repetitive Points of Order were used to frustrate proceedings, injections from some councillors and people in the Public Gallery were common and finishing times were extending long past midnight.

Upon being elected as mayor, I made it clear that I wanted to make improving our dysfunctional meetings my immediate priority.

The following are the reforms which I implemented and which each contributed to the immediate and sustained improvement of councillor performance in the Council Chamber and the return to efficient functioning of our meetings:

  1. 1983The appointment of an independent Governance and Behaviour Monitor to oversee performance (including to impartially review my performance as chair);
  2. The adoption of Supplementary Standing Orders to provide the most comprehensive meeting procedures in Victorian local government;
  3. Disincentivising the repetitive and belligerent use of Points of Order and Procedural Motions to prolong meetings and detract from debating the real issues of substance;
  4. A strengthened Councillor Code of Conduct;
  5. Introducing an improved audio system for Council meetings to allow for better control of meetings by the chairperson;
  6. Setting clear boundaries on the finishing times for Council meetings and making meetings efficient; and
  7. Holding all councillors accountable for their attendances at Council meetings.

These reforms have fixed the previous dysfunction and disorder.

Council meetings are now efficiently and effectively conducted with debate free-flowing but with no irrelevant Points of Order, heckling or interjections.

The substantial improvement in the conduct of our meetings can be observed in the monthly reports from the independent Governance and Behaviour Monitor who I recommended to Council be appointed as an accountability measure through to the October elections.

A reflection on the 2012-16 Council term

Posted by on 4:18 pm in Councillor performance, Effective meetings, Financial management, Improving efficiency, Improving services, News, Record | 0 comments

A reflection on the 2012-16 Council term

The following is my end of term address which I delivered to the last Monash Council meeting of the 2012-16 term on Wednesday, 19 October 2016.   Given this is the last Council meeting for this term of Council, I would like to make a few comments looking back over the past four years. Reflecting on these four years this afternoon, it occurred to me that I don’t think there has ever been a period of such rapid change and new initiatives in the 22 year history of Monash Council. The election of most us in October 2012 now seems much...

read more

Fixing Council’s dysfunctional meetings – reports from the independent monitor

Posted by on 11:06 pm in Councillor performance, Effective meetings, Record | 0 comments

Fixing Council’s dysfunctional meetings – reports from the independent monitor

There was a protracted period leading up to my election as mayor in May 2016 where meetings of Council had experienced a pronounced decline in behavioural standards amongst a small group of councillors and persons in the Public Gallery. In response to this, Council resolved at the May 2016 meeting to support my recommendations to: introduce Supplementary Standing Orders to supplement its Meeting Procedures Local Law No 1 to strengthen conduct requirements at meetings; and establish the short term position of an independent Governance and...

read more

Improving Council meetings: A new audio system

Posted by on 8:30 am in Councillor performance, Effective meetings | 0 comments

Improving Council meetings: A new audio system

One of the challenges in maintaining order at Council meetings for the chairperson was not having effective control over the microphones and amplification equipment in the Council Chamber. The amplification and audio system in the Council Chamber was showing its age and was in need of renewal. At the 31 May 2016 Council meeting, Council accepted my recommendation that Council officers as a matter of priority implement improvements to the quality of the audio system so that amplification of our proceedings is improved for all persons in the...

read more

Councillors censured for not attending meetings and not providing apologies

Posted by on 2:01 pm in Councillor performance, Effective meetings, News | 0 comments

Councillors censured for not attending meetings and not providing apologies

At a special Council meeting on 19 July 2016, Council resolved its frustration that Cr Theo Zographos and Cr Robert Davies were not showing the professional courtesy to Council or the community they represent by providing apologies in advance of meetings missed or providing reasonable notice of a planned extended absence. At the special meeting of Council, the Council resolved to require that Cr Zographos and Cr Davies provide certain apologies and undertakings to Council in relation to improving their conduct. Neither Cr Zographos or Cr...

read more

Improving councillor attendances at meetings

Posted by on 8:53 am in Councillor performance, Effective meetings | 0 comments

Improving councillor attendances at meetings

I called a special meeting of Council on 19 July 2016 to consider issues relating to councillors not turning up to meetings and not providing reasonable notice of apologies. I had become alarmed at the attendance record of some councillors and, in particular, the approach that some councillors were taking in either providing no prior apology when they are absent from a Council meeting or providing unreasonable or insufficient notice of a planned extended absence. All councillors who are elected to Monash Council are aware that Monash Council...

read more

Fixing dysfunctional meetings: stopping disruptive Points of Order

Posted by on 10:58 pm in Councillor performance, Effective meetings, Record | 0 comments

Fixing dysfunctional meetings: stopping disruptive Points of Order

Past meetings of Council prior to my election as mayor had seen a pronounced decline in behavioural standards amongst a small group of councillors and persons in the Public Gallery. This had led to meetings being unacceptably unruly, disruptive and unpleasant.  In particular, there have been a number of instances where these councillors or persons in the Public Gallery have completely disregarded the rulings or directions of the previous mayor.  A number of complaints have been made in response to this conduct. It is important that Council...

read more

Fixing Council meetings: A strengthened Councillor Code of Conduct

Posted by on 2:17 pm in Councillor performance, Effective meetings | 0 comments

Fixing Council meetings: A strengthened Councillor Code of Conduct

Prior to my election as mayor, Council meetings had seen a pronounced decline in behavioural standards amongst a small group of councillors.  This had led to meetings being unacceptably unruly, disruptive and unpleasant.  In particular, there had been a number of instances where these councillors had completely disregarded the rulings or directions of the previous mayor.  A number of complaints have been made in response to this conduct. It is important that Council takes action to require all councillors to observe reasonable professional...

read more

Fixing dysfunctional meetings: ensuring efficient meetings

Posted by on 8:08 am in Councillor performance, Effective meetings, Record | 0 comments

Fixing dysfunctional meetings: ensuring efficient meetings

Upon my election to fill the vacancy in the position of Mayor three weeks ago, I signalled to Council and the community that restoring the orderly and respectful functioning of Council meetings would be my main focus in the role. Preceding my election as mayor, the previous three meetings of Council had finished at midnight, 3.00 am and 11.30 pm, respectively, which are well past the latest finishing time contemplated by Local Law No 1 of 10.00 pm.  This concerning trend of excessively late finishing times indicates that Council is not...

read more

Fixing dysfunctional meetings: appointment of an independent Monitor

Posted by on 10:31 pm in Councillor performance, Effective meetings, Record | 0 comments

Fixing dysfunctional meetings: appointment of an independent Monitor

Past meetings of Council have seen a pronounced decline in behavioural standards amongst a small group of Councillors and persons in the Public Gallery.  This has led to meetings being unacceptably unruly, disruptive and unpleasant. In particular, there have been a number of instances where these Councillors or persons in the Public Gallery have completely disregarded the rulings or directions of the previous Mayor.  A number of complaints have been made in response to this conduct. It is important that Council takes action to restore its...

read more

Fixing unruly meetings: tough new Supplementary Standing Orders

Posted by on 10:58 pm in Councillor performance, Effective meetings, Record | 0 comments

Fixing unruly meetings: tough new Supplementary Standing Orders

Upon my election to fill the vacancy in the position of Mayor three weeks ago, I signalled to Council and the community that restoring the orderly and respectful functioning of Council meetings would be my main focus in the role. Council meetings had been rapidly descending into chaos with finishing times extending well past midnight and regular disruptive and unruly conduct by both some councillors and some members of the Public Gallery. This is an example of the sort of conduct which was regularly occurring: This was illegally shot from the...

read more